Connect with us

2016 F1

F1 paddock divided over ‘musical chairs’ qualifying



F1 paddock divided over 'musical chairs' qualifying

F1 paddock divided over ‘musical chairs’ qualifying

Paddock opinion at the Barcelona test has been divided in two, after the FIA confirmed that the F1 Commission in Geneva “unanimously” approved a new qualifying format.

Mercedes team chairman Niki Lauda had been the first to hail the move to revamp the current ‘knockout’ format by eliminating a slowest car every 90 seconds.

Red Bull’s Christian Horner agrees.

“It could create a bit more randomness for the grid on Sunday, without artificially inverting grids,” he said.

And Nico Rosberg said: “I think it’s always good when we question our sport and try to bring fresh aspects into it.”

Actually reversing the grids – earlier slammed as a “disaster” by Romain Grosjean – had been F1 supremo Bernie Ecclestone’s real preference, with the 90-second knockout idea apparently a close second choice and compromise.

It means that, having slammed the state of today’s F1 just days ago, the 85-year-old is now much more upbeat about the future.

“I think now I’d be a bit more confident that we are going to see some good racing,” Ecclestone is quoted by British newspapers including the Telegraph.

“I wasn’t talking down the sport at all, quite the opposite. I was trying to sort of explain that unless we did something, that’s the way we’d be going.”

Some said qualifying will now be like ‘musical chairs’, in an action-packed scramble to avoid being the next to be left with a low grid position.

“It’s a strange idea,” said Renault rookie Jolyon Palmer, “as I don’t see it will make a massive difference.” But Daniil Kvyat had the opposite view, admitting that at first sight he thought qualifying will now be “a mess”.

Kimi Raikkonen, testing the new Ferrari for the first time on Wednesday, did not want to comment at all, remarking: “Let’s wait to see if it happens.”

But Williams’ Felipe Massa said: “I have not given it a lot of thought, but the intention is clear: to produce some chaos.”

His boss Pat Symonds agrees with that assessment.

“I don’t think it’s going to improve qualifying itself and in fact there is a danger qualifying might not be as exciting. What it has a good chance of doing is improving the race.

“We will see some of the quicker cars a bit further back and we all know that has given us some great races in the past,” he added.

Nico Hulkenberg is alarmed at the timing of the qualifying shakeup.

“It was a huge surprise that, three weeks before the start of the season, the qualifying format is rewritten,” said the Force India driver and reigning Le Mans winner.

Symonds agrees: “We made our tyre choices for the first races on the basis of the old qualifying, so I’m sure if we had known about this, we might have chosen something else.

“But we’re all in the same boat,” he added.

Toro Rosso driver Carlos Sainz is also in two minds.

“On one hand, it looks good because it will be spectacular, but it might be a bit hard to explain what is going on. But as long as it is spectacular, people will like it,” he said.

However, it is clear from the reaction on social media that the fans are very much divided over whether ‘musical chairs’ qualifying is a good idea.

“We should always try to be better,” argues Haas team boss Gunther Steiner. “Sometimes you are wrong but it can be corrected.

“But I think the fans will like the new format.”

Jos Verstappen, a former F1 driver and the father of Toro Rosso teen sensation Max, is also trying to keep an open mind.

“I think the old system was not too bad. I found it pretty exciting, especially the last two minutes of the session,” he told

“But I think they want to spread the excitement of those last two minutes. It’s easy to say ‘I don’t like it’, but maybe it’s something great,” said Jos.

“What people want to see is racing,” Verstappen added. “They don’t want to know who is going to win in advance, and that is now the case.”


Latest Results

Latest F1 News

2018 F14 hours ago

Race Analysis: 2018 German Grand Prix

  Lewis Hamilton won a chaotic German Grand Prix at the Hockenheimring circuit, starting from 14th on the grid, the...

2018 F114 hours ago

Hamilton escapes race ban penalty for pit entry incident

Lewis Hamilton has escaped a race ban penalty following the investigation by race stewards at Hockenheim summoned him over a...

2018 F115 hours ago

Hamilton’s German GP victory under threat

Lewis Hamilton’s German Grand Prix victory is under investigation following the race stewards at Hockenheim summoned him over a possible...

2018 F116 hours ago

Hamilton wins German GP from 14th as Vettel crashes out

Lewis Hamilton started from 14th on the grid to a 66th F1 career victory, and back into the lead of...

2018 F117 hours ago

Race Results – German Grand Prix

2018 F1 world championship results – Round Eleven – Results in 2018 German Formula 1 Grand Prix, Sunday Race results...

2018 F121 hours ago

Mercedes’ paranoia: Blame and Acceptance

Mercedes and Lewis Hamilton have had some interesting remarks about Ferrari, after the latter’s spurt in performance at the German...

2018 F122 hours ago

F1 shocked as Ferrari president departs

The F1 paddock at Hockenheim is shocked that Ferrari’s president Sergio Marchionne has suddenly departed the team and formula one....

2018 F122 hours ago

Starting Grid: German Grand Prix

The local hero, Sebastian Vettel took his 55th F1 career pole position in front of his home crowd at Hockenheimring...

2018 F123 hours ago

Alonso says he will leave F1 before 2021

Fernando Alonso says he will not be in formula one in 2021. At Hockenheim, the paddock is abuzz with news...

2018 F124 hours ago

Wolff admits Mercedes falling behind Ferrari engine power

Mercedes has admitted it is falling clearly behind Ferrari in engine power. Lewis Hamilton’s main problem in Hockenheim qualifying was...

Most Popular is not affiliated with Formula 1, Formula One Management, Formula One Administration, Formula One Licensing BV, Formula One World Championship Ltd or any other organization or entity associated with the official Formula One governing organizations or their shareholders. Copyrighted material used under Fair Use/Fair Comment.

We could use the following leading F1 news sources for stories: SkyF1, BBC F1, Autosport, ESPN F1, FIA Media Center, MotorSport, JamesAllen and others leading authors blog.

All Rights Reserved © 2017 Prime Sport Media